Praise be to Allaah.
The regular Muslim who cannot access
the proofs (daleels) or understand them in the way that scholars do
is obliged to consult and follow the scholars. Allaah says (interpretation
of the meaning):
“So ask of those who know the Scripture,
if you do not know” [al-Nahl 16:43]
But in the case of those who can arrive at the
correct view on a matter by examining the evidence, it is not permissible
for them to follow, unless they do not have the time to research the
matter. In that case, they come under the same ruling as a regular Muslim
who does not have enough knowledge.
-
Shaykh ‘Abd al-Kareem
al-Khudayr
There is nothing wrong with learning
fiqh according to one of the four madhhabs, on condition that one follows
the daleel (evidence) if it becomes apparent that the madhhab says something
contrary to the daleel on a given matter, because obedience to Allaah
and His Messenger comes before obedience to anyone else. It is also
essential to have good manners towards other schools of thought and
not to develop sectarian attitudes in opposing them. He should make
the truth his aim and respect the opinions and efforts (ijtihaad) of
the scholars. He should make discussing matters with them in a polite
manner his method of reaching the truth, and he should advise people
in a polite way if he thinks that they are mistaken.
It is wrong for a person who is
able to learn to refuse to do so on the grounds that only the scholars
are able to understand the daleel. We do not say to one who is unable
to engage in ijtihaad that he has to strive to derive rulings from the
texts when he does not have the ability to do that and does not understand
the principles; otherwise chaos would reign. But we do say that if you
have some knowledge and understanding, you should at least know what
the proof and daleel of your imaam (whom you are following) is, so that
you can see the connection with the Qur’aan and Sunnah, and you can
follow with some measure of insight and not be merely a bind follower.
And Allaah is the Source of strength
and the Guide to the Straight Path.